Orange Beach council upholds decision on Phoenix Key project

John Mullen • June 10, 2022

Neighboring owners are worried about effects on nearby properties

Brett Robinson is adding Phoenix Key with 112 units in Orange Beach, Alabama.

Orange Beach, Ala. – (OBA) – Orange Beach’s decision to allow Phoenix Key condo towers east of Perdido Pass was the subject of the city’s first appeal from a planning commission on its decision on a new Phoenix project.



The project received a favorable vote at the April 11 Planning Commission meeting by 5-1 with board president Robert Stuart abstaining because he manages property near the proposed site. Since the developers are staying within the letter of the zoning law for the property there was no need for city council approval.


Residents of nearby Dolphin Key on the Gulf and Dolphin Harbor on Old River were at the council meeting and expressed concerns about the affects the project would have on surrounding property. In the end, the council upheld the planning commission’s decision.


At Phoenix Key, it will have identical towers and containing 56 units each. Brett Robinson is currently underway with Phoenix Gulf Towers in the western part of the city between Sugar Beach and Palm Place condominiums. Each those buildings will have 96 units for a total of 192 with 24 two-bedroom units, 24 three-bedroom units and 48 four-bedroom units in each tower.


This put the total number of buildings or hotels developed by Brett Robinson in Orange Beach and Gulf Shores at 23. In recent years, Brett Robinson has added Phoenix Gulf Shores on West Beach Boulevard near the Pier 33 Grocery store, Phoenix Orange Beach west of the Hampton Inn in Orange Beach and recently completed Phoenix Orange Beach II east of the Island House Hotel. Phoenix Gulf Shores II is also under construction on East Beach Boulevard across from the Comfort Inn.


During the regular session, the council:


  • Approved a liquor license for CoastAL currently under construction near the intersection of State Route 161 and State Route 182 in Orange Beach. The project’s second phase will include a residents’ parking lot and beach access on the west side of the beachfront property.


  • OK’d a resolution adopting new rental policies, procedures and fees for the Wind and Water learning Center. The city is making the center available for daylong and half-day rental of the facility with capacity for about 49 persons. Renters would have the use of the sailboat loft, beach, restrooms, outdoor picnic area, kitchen with fridge, microwave and coffee maker. There is a separate pay scale for residents and nonresidents. The grounds excluding using the inside would also be available for two-hour rentals.


  • Awarded a bid for $135,230 to J. Reed Constructors to refurbish the fire training tower behind Fire Station No. 1. It was the only bid received for the project.


  • Awarded a bid for Canal Road widening from State Route 161 to Wilson Boulevard for $7.4 million to John G. Walton Construction. The project will be partially funded with RESTORE Act funds and the city is contributing $3.5 million.


  • OK’d a resolution authorizing execution of a professional services agreement with John Holladay for football coaching services for $40,000 and preapproved expenses associated with the job.


  • OK’d a resolution authorizing execution of a temporary staffing agreement with Long's Personnel Services.     

  • OK’d a resolution authorizing the execution of a subscription agreement with Active Network for point-of-sale, activity registration and facility reservation software for $28,000 a year. The city has contracted with Active Network since 2019 and uses its services for the Coast Arts Center, sports and recreation, Expect Excellence, sail camp, art camp, swim lessons, junior lifeguard training, the Sportsplex, the Events Center and will soon be used by the Performing Arts Center. It was used for golf cart registration as well as Freedom Fest merchandise sales.


  • OK’d the donation of 600 chairs owned by the city as surplus and unneeded to the city of Foley.


  • OK’d the purchase of bleachers for the Sportsplex for $72,600.


  • OK’d the purchase of a commercial washer and dryer for the Sportsplex through the BuyBoard purchasing cooperative in the amount of $20,262.   


  • Had a public hearing on a $1 million grant the city is considering to Point Broadband “to provide additional funding for the construction, installation and placement of optic services” west of State Route 161. The council will also consider a resolution giving the money to Point Broadband after the hearing.


  • Had a public hearing and introduction of an ordinance change to allow Turquoise Place to build a four-story parking garage with amenities directly east of the condo towers.


  • Rescheduled a public hearing and an introduction of an ordinance for a change in the Parks Edge planned unit development specifically related to the lot at 31 Parks Edge.


During the work session, the council discussed:


  • Executing a RESTORE grant agreement with the state for expansion of the Orange Beach Wildlife Rehabilitation and Education Program. The $424,450 grant is 100 percent reimbursable and the city will ask for an additional $200,000 from the RESTORE council for this project.


  • Declaring emergency conditions at a home at 29709 Bayshore Drive North in Bear Point to be a “danger presented to the safety and welfare of the general public and further orders said property to be cleared at the expense of the owner.” City documents also say owners Rodney and Bethany Hogan were contacted with two certified letters, one in November and a second in February and the city received no response.


  • Appropriating $91,000 to Gulf Shores Orange Beach Sports & Events to help with sports tourism on the Alabama Gulf Coast.


  • Appropriating a one-time lump sum payment to the state of Alabama Employees’ Retirement System. An act of the legislature allows these payments to any retirees or their beneficiaries at the rate of $2 for every month served as a state employee which would be a total cost to the city of about $36,000.


  • Appropriating $259,833 to the Makos Academics, Arts & Athletics Club for coaching supplements for camps run at Orange Beach Middle and High School.


  • A resolution authorizing an agreement Granicus for address identification and rental activity monitoring.


  • Amend the city ordinance on flood damage prevention to include mechanical and electrical equipment elevation requirements.


  • An ordinance change to annex about 1,400 more of County Road 95 into the city limits and take over maintenance. The portion is from South Bayou Lane northwest until county maintenance resumes. On May 3, the Baldwin County Commission OK’d the petition.

Share this article w/ Friends...

Foley Adds New Lights to Highlight Historic Downtown
By OBA Staff November 15, 2025
Foley, Ala. — (OBA) — Foley is getting ready to brighten its historic downtown even more. City leaders are moving ahead with a plan to add new lights to outline more buildings in the business district. The project has already changed how the area looks at night. Now, officials say the second phase will expand that...
Orange Beach Schools Continue Rise With Strong 2025 Performance
By OBA Staff November 15, 2025
Orange Beach, Ala. — (OBA) — Orange Beach City Schools has earned one of the highest scores in Alabama on the 2025 State Report Card, posting a 98 and placing the small coastal system among the state’s elite. District leaders say the score reflects years of focused work. They also point to strong teaching, committed...
Love Nette: How One Woman’s ‘Amazing Grace’ Inspired a Community
By Erica Thomas November 14, 2025
Orange Beach, Ala. — (OBA) — That was the last message Nette Fairey publicly shared on Facebook in 2023, and by all accounts, she lived that way. She took to social media to inspire others and her legacy continues through those who were touched by her inspirational words and Bible verses.
Foley Continues to Expand Sidewalk Network Along Alabama Hwy 59
By OBA Staff November 14, 2025
Foley, Ala. — (OBA) — Foley city leaders are taking another step toward improving pedestrian access across the community. The Foley City Council has approved plans to add more sidewalks along Alabama Hwy. 59, continuing an ongoing effort to make the city safer and more pedestrian-friendly. Officials said the...
Makos Signing Day Photo by Brent Williams, Wolf Bay Photography
By OBA Staff November 13, 2025
Orange Beach, Ala. — (OBA) — Orange Beach High School hosted a Signing Day ceremony for its senior softball players. The event recognized five Makos who committed to continuing their careers in college. School staff organized the program to highlight each senior. The purpose was to officially sign scholarship...
Gulf Shores Students and Staff Rally for Make Waves of Kindness
By OBA Staff November 13, 2025
Gulf Shores, Ala. — (OBA) — Gulf Shores City Schools will celebrate its annual Make Waves of Kindness Day with students, staff, and families taking part across all campuses. The event aligns with a broader community push for inclusion and recognition of neurodiversity. Organizers say the goal is to build daily...
Gulf Shores Gears Up for Fun and Fundraising with .7K Charity Run Crawl Walk and Dunk Booth
By OBA Staff November 13, 2025
Gulf Shores, Ala. — (OBA) — Gulf Shores is getting ready to mix laughter, community spirit, and a little friendly competition in one of the most entertaining charity events of the year. Sunny 105 will host the first-ever .7K Crawl-Walk-Run, with Tacky Jack's featuring the Dunk-A-Local Celebrity fundraiser on Saturday,
The Wharf Plans Festive Events With Lights Music and Family Fun
By OBA Staff November 12, 2025
Orange Beach, Ala. — (OBA) — The Wharf is rolling out a full lineup of holiday events that blend classic traditions with new surprises. Organizers say families can expect movies, music, shopping deals, and plenty of free activities. Visitors will see festive lights and themed photo spots across Main Street and Portside
Brits Find Their Southern Soul in Orange Beach
By R. Ken Cooper November 12, 2025
Orange Beach, Ala. — (OBA) — For British travelers Jack and Paige, exploring the United States has turned into a deep love affair with one state in particular — Alabama. From the rolling hills of Huntsville to the tides of Orange Beach, their cross-state adventure captures everything that makes Alabama shine: Southern
Work continues to improve Pilgrim Street in southeast Foley.
By OBA Staff November 12, 2025
Foley, Ala. — (OBA) — Work along Pilgrim Street in southeast Foley will soon include more improvements after the Foley City Council approved additional upgrades to the street extension and walking trail near Beulah Heights Park. The project is part of the city’s efforts to improve access while preserving natural...
Show More